Roger Coe Eddy edited begin_section_Introduction_Preliminary_efforts__.tex  over 6 years ago

Commit id: 975b21479b88ddb8d209d1d3f4eeec1a7dbb1ca7

deletions | additions      

       

While computers speed up these tools, all that is necessary is pencil and paper. We hope these tools may be useful in worlds as different as academic medical centers and pre-literate tribal societies. \textit{Literacy Bridge} a clever and effective program produces changes in maternal and child health and agriculture by supporting communication with spoken word devices.  \marginnote{-2}{\emph{Literacy \marginnote[-2]{\emph{Literacy  Bridge}A description of the program that illustrates how word of mouth transmission, clever personal devices and advanced program design support community education and development can be found at \url{www.literacybridge.com}} \subsection{Complexity}  Complex systems have multiple parts. Human use the technical parts and interact with other humans, introducing communication. All this is in constant change over time. I stumbled upon this example on the internet. We could consider the magnets as non-human parts of the system, marbles as humans, and sticks and pieces of wood as designed control factors to keep the components in a safe range. We can see there are many ways things can go wrong and how hard it is to modify one part without unexpected results elsewhere. Note there could be a cascading series of minor defects in the system that could result in a complete breakdown. We will return to that idea. Also note that while the marbles are almost passive once they are set in motion, humans can observe and react in complex processes in which they find themselves. Richard Cook in the next section feels this is how expert participants can pick up errors in progress and intervene to change the course of events. To perform in that way they must have learned thru mistakes. That is how knowledge is acquired and generalized to new situations. \marginnote{Marbles and Magnets. Use the link to the video and click on the arrow to show the operation of a model of a complex system. If you can, use the full screen view. \url{http://www.eetimes.com/author.asp?section_id=216&doc_id=1329692}}\\  \subsection{Investigating and Defining Complex Systems Failure} This area has been investigated extensively and from many points of view. A summary of important considerations concerning health care is found at the Cognitve Technologies Lab in a handout by Richard I. Cook: \textit{How Complex Systems Fail } accessible as full text through Research Gate. One of the problems of research in this area is the view from the top down is strongly influenced by the language and habits of the different disciplines, they are looking for a particular canary in the coal mine, one from the areas with which they are familiar and were they can develop testable hypotheses. From the ground, the bottom up, the case report, the life story, the perspective is somewhat different. We do not want to miss something just because it is new, or rare or unfamiliar to us. One of the most troubling problems in medicine is the patient who presents with something unexpected or unknown to us. They are frequently blamed for not having the right picture to fit our expectations. They are blamed for imagining something or come to feel they are hypochondriacs. One of my OB/Gyn professors drummed into our minds the "first symptom of carcinoma of the cervix is no symptoms." \marginnote{-2}{\url{https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228797158} \marginnote[-2]{\url{https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228797158}  Many additional papers are available through Research Gate where you can select those appropriate to your own interests.} \subsection{Extending an Investigation}  While we began with specific incidents we found in order to have an adequate context we needed both a wider and a deeper look. In the literature this is called \emph {thick description} an idea introduced by Gilbert Ryle, a philosopher of Mind ,\cite{Ryle1971a}and popularized by Clifford Geertz, an anthropologist, who applied the idea in field work in Bali. \cite{Geertz1973}. In our reflection tools the deeper look is expressed in the Narrative Report, the wider look is the result of the Complex Context Critcal Incident Report. The SwampNote is the basic description of one view of an incident and the author's view including their feeling state. In repeated use observation and description are sharpened. Several notes may contribute to a Narrative Report and/or a CCCIR. We provide samples of the tools in Section 4 and clarify how they relate to each other and how they can and should be adapted to local, on the ground conditions. The next sections explain what situations and questions led us to develop this way of looking at important life incidents.