Kim H. Parker edited untitled.tex  almost 9 years ago

Commit id: c830797ec5218ffb8824562280644242d62f81b9

deletions | additions      

       

The last third of the paper, starting with the final sentence of the section 'Summary of Wave Separation and WIA' is, riddled with errors of interpretation and, more importantly, contains a number of false factual statements that need to be corrected. Instead of dealing with these errors chronologically, I think that it is better to point out the fundamental errors first and then to deal with their sequela.  (A note on notation:  In their paper they use RWC to refer to the reservoir wave concept whereas we tend to use 'reservoir wave hypothesis'. As a convenient compromise I will use the abbreviation Pr for reservoir pressure. pressure except when quoting from their paper when I will us their notation $P_{res}$.  We both use the abbreviation iFR for the instantaneous wave-free ratio.