Alberto Pepe deleted file While_it_tori_and.tex  about 11 years ago

Commit id: 6ef64f2fae649325ff9806fbd56c59a5efeaafe8

deletions | additions      

         

While {\it tori} and {\it riq} remove the largest systematic problems with  citation counts, they are citation-derived measures and, as such,   they necessarily suffer from two systematic problems of citation  counts which  do not lend themselves to programmatic solutions. First, it is not in  general possible to tell the differing contributions of various  co-authors to a paper ({\it tori} assumes all authors contribute equally ---  a technique obviously more correct in the aggregate than for any individual paper).  Modifications, such as giving extra weight to the first (or last) author are necessarily ad hoc and discipline-dependent stratagems. The second fundamental problem with the use of citations for the evaluation of  individuals is that citations chiefly measure usefulness  While usefulness can be correlated with importance, these are clearly  different concepts; oftentimes, importance is what is actually desired.