Valproic acid may be tested in patients with H3F3A-mutated high-grade gliomas

Letter to the editor

The first reports (Happold 2016) of a possible effect of valproic acid in the outcome of patients with glioblastoma were published nearly at the same time as the first ever description of the driver role of histone mutations in a human cancer - significantly enough in pediatric and young adult patients with glioblastoma (Schwartzentruber 2012). Since then, a few retrospective reports have added clinical information that fueled the hypothesis of valproic acid effect in the survival of glioblastoma patients, via HDAC-inhibiting effect. Now, the report of Happold et al (Happold 2016) may have seemingly poured cold water upon this idea. Without a shadow of doubt, Happold’s report is the best evidence about this question that has been provided so far. Even though someone may put forward a number of well grounded critiques to their findings, this will be mostly worthless given the weaknesses of the previous evidence.

One particular type of bias that seems to be very common in retrospective accounts of would-be repurposed drugs is the immortal time bias (Ho 2012) (aka survivor bias). This kind of problem arises when one has to forcefully add the pre-therapy events (deaths, in this case) to the non-treated group (because such patients never had the opportunity to receive the therapy of interest, they have died before!). It is very easy and amusing to demonstrate that any such an arrangement of an observational cohort study will necessarily suggest a beneficial effect of the treatment.

As Happold et al has cited (Happold 2016), our group was the one that originally published retrospective data suggesting a possible effect of valproic acid in pediatric patients with brain tumors. Our original account included a heterogeneous group of patients, but since then, we published other reports studying more homogeneous cohorts of patients, with mixed results (Felix 2012). Recently, we presented a poster in a Brazillian Society of Pediatric Oncology Congress with new data on the outcome of diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG) patients treated with a contemporary radiochemotherapy protocol and valproic acid (Felix 2015). We showed a small cohort of 9 patients with DIPG treated with valproic acid throughout the observation time. This group of patients had a 6-month survival of 86% and a 12-month survival of 64%. While this could be regarded as reassuring and an indication for further investigation, we acknowledge that the number of patients is too small and any comparison would be severely underpowered. However, one of the mainstays of investigational clinical science (and one that is too frequently forgotten) is to gather prior information about the therapy of interest and the target cohort. Mixed results from mixed groups of patients are hardly conclusive of anything, so we must examine thoroughly the rationale for any proposed treatment.

In this particular case, evidence has been building up that points to a subset of pediatric high-grade gliomas that depends on histone H3.3 (H3F3A gene) mutations (Wu 2012, Bender 2013, Solomon 2015). To be specific, pediatric patients with DIPG and midline glioblastomas harboring the H3F3A-K27M mutation comprise a subgroup with a particularly poor prognosis, compared to other patients. Mutations K27M of H3.3 and H3.1 histones define two mutually exclusive DIPG subgroups that differ in biology, behavior and prognosis (Castel 2015). The H3F3A-K27M mutant cells seem to globally loose methylation markers of H3.3 and undergo a bulk derepression of epigenetically silenced genes, while focally gaining methylation H3.3 sites, thus repressing the expression of selected genes (Chan 2013). Even though its mechanism is incompletely understood, it is possible that H3F3A-K27M may render tumor cells more sensitive to HDAC inhibitors like valproic acid. So, there is a strong rationale from recently-gathered evidence for the use of HDAC inhibitor drugs in patients with H3-mutant tumors. Most of them will be children, adolescents and young adults with DIPG and midline glioblastomas. We propose that future trials exploring this possibility select the patients by this molecular marker, including DIPG and glioblastoma patients with H3F3A-K27M mutation, and excluding other patients that may not benefit from the treatment.

Published at Journal of Clinical Oncology. Cite as:

Felix F, Fontenele J. Valproic Acid May Be Tested in Patients With H3F3A-Mutated High-Grade Gliomas JCO Jun 13, 2016:JCO.2016.67.1073v1-JCO671073

Link to the published version:

Figure 1: T2-weighted MRI showing the characteristic image findings in DIPG. A diffuse pons enlargement with T2-signal alteration. Basilar artery is “engulfed” in the pathologically enlarged pons


  1. C. Happold, T. Gorlia, O. Chinot, M. R. Gilbert, L. B. Nabors, W. Wick, S. L. Pugh, M. Hegi, T. Cloughesy, P. Roth, D. A. Reardon, J. R. Perry, M. P. Mehta, R. Stupp, M. Weller. Does Valproic Acid or Levetiracetam Improve Survival in Glioblastoma? A Pooled Analysis of Prospective Clinical Trials in Newly Diagnosed Glioblastoma. Journal of Clinical Oncology (2016). Link

  2. Jeremy Schwartzentruber, Andrey Korshunov, Xiao-Yang Liu, David T. W. Jones, Elke Pfaff, Karine Jacob, Dominik Sturm, Adam M. Fontebasso, Dong-Anh Khuong Quang, Martje Tönjes, Volker Hovestadt, Steffen Albrecht, Marcel Kool, Andre Nantel, Carolin Konermann, Anders Lindroth, Natalie Jäger, Tobias Rausch, Marina Ryzhova, Jan O. Korbel, Thomas Hielscher, Peter Hauser, Miklos Garami, Almos Klekner, Laszlo Bognar, Martin Ebinger, Martin U. Schuhmann, Wolfram Scheurlen, Arnulf Pekrun, Michael C. Frühwald, Wolfgang Roggendorf, Christoph Kramm, Matthias Dürken, Jeffrey Atkinson, Pierre Lepage, Alexandre Montpetit, Magdalena Zakrzewska, Krzystof Zakrzewski, Pawel P. Liberski, Zhifeng Dong, Peter Siegel, Andreas E. Kulozik, Marc Zapatka, Abhijit Guha, David Malkin, Jörg Felsberg, Guido Reifenberger, Andreas von Deimling, Koichi Ichimura, V. Peter Collins, Hendrik Witt, Till Milde, Olaf Witt, Cindy Zhang, Pedro Castelo-Branco, Peter Lichter, Damien Faury, Uri Tabori, Christoph Plass, Jacek Majewski, Stefan M. Pfister, Nada Jabado. Driver mutations in histone H3.3 and chromatin remodelling genes in paediatric glioblastoma. Nature 482, 226–231 (2012). Link

  3. A. M.-H. Ho, P. W. Dion, C. S. H. Ng, M. K. Karmakar. Understanding immortal time bias in observational cohort studies. Anaesthesia 68, 126–130 (2012). Link

  4. F. H. C. Felix, O. L. de Araujo, K. M. da Trindade, N. M. Trompieri, J. B. Fontenele. Survival of children with malignant brain tumors receiving valproate: a retrospective study. Childs Nerv Syst 29, 195–197 (2012). Link

  5. Francisco Felix, Juvenia Fontenele. Chemoradiotherapy with etoposide cisplatin, and ifosfamide associated with valproic acid for patients with diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma [v1; not peer reviewed]. F1000Research 2015 4, 1301 (poster) [Portuguese] (2015). Link

  6. Gang Wu, Alberto Broniscer, Troy A McEachron, Charles Lu, Barbara S Paugh, Jared Becksfort, Chunxu Qu, Li Ding, Robert Huether, Matthew Parker, Junyuan Zhang, Amar Gajjar, Michael A Dyer, Charles G Mullighan, Richard J Gilbertson, Elaine R Mardis, Richard K Wilson, James R Downing, David W Ellison, Jinghui Zhang, Suzanne J Baker. Somatic histone H3 alterations in pediatric diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas and non-brainstem glioblastomas. Nature Genetics 44, 251–253 (2012). Link

  7. Sebastian Bender, Yujie Tang, Anders M. Lindroth, Volker Hovestadt, David T.W. Jones, Marcel Kool, Marc Zapatka, Paul A. Northcott, Dominik Sturm, Wei Wang, Bernhard Radlwimmer, Jonas W. H, Nathalène Truffaux, David Castel, Simone Schubert, Marina Ryzhova, Huriye -Cin, Jan Gronych, Pascal David Johann, Sebastian Stark, Jochen Meyer, Till Milde, Martin Schuhmann, Martin Ebinger, Camelia-Maria Monoranu, Anitha Ponnuswami, Spenser Chen, Chris Jones, Olaf Witt, V. Peter Collins, Andreas von Deimling, Nada Jabado, Stephanie Puget, Jacques Grill, Kristian Helin, Andrey Korshunov, Peter Lichter, Michelle Monje, Christoph Plass, Yoon-Jae Cho, Stefan M. Pfister. Reduced H3K27me3 and DNA Hypomethylation Are Major Drivers of Gene Expression in K27M Mutant Pediatric High-Grade Gliomas. Cancer Cell 24, 660–672 (2013). Link

  8. David A. Solomon, Matthew D. Wood, Tarik Tihan, Andrew W. Bollen, Nalin Gupta, Joanna J. J. Phillips, Arie Perry. Diffuse Midline Gliomas with Histone H3-K27M Mutation: A Series of 47 Cases Assessing the Spectrum of Morphologic Variation and Associated Genetic Alterations. Brain Pathology n/a–n/a (2015). Link

  9. David Castel, Cathy Philippe, Raphaël Calmon, Ludivine Le Dret, Nathalène Truffaux, Nathalie Boddaert, Mélanie Pagès, Kathryn R. Taylor, Patrick Saulnier, Ludovic Lacroix, Alan Mackay, Chris Jones, Christian Sainte-Rose, Thomas Blauwblomme, Felipe Andreiuolo, Stephanie Puget, Jacques Grill, Pascale Varlet, Marie-Anne Debily. Histone H3F3A and HIST1H3B K27M mutations define two subgroups of diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas with different prognosis and phenotypes. Acta Neuropathologica 130, 815–827 (2015). Link

  10. Kui Ming Chan, Jing Han, Dong Fang, Haiyun Gan, Zhiguo Zhang. A lesson learned from the H3.3K27M mutation found in pedia