The total energy transfer from the solar wind to the magnetosphere is governed by the reconnection rate at the magnetosphere edges as the IMF $B_z$ turns southward. The delayed response of the ring current to solar wind driving can account for the anomalous growth of the SYM-H under northward IMF $B_z$. The geomagnetic storm on 21-22 January 2005 is considered to be anomalous as the SYM-H index that signifies the strength of ring current, grows and has a sustained peak value lasting more than 6 hrs under northward IMF $B_z$ conditions. In this work, first the standard WINDMI model is utilized to estimate the growth and decay of various magnetospheric currents by using several solar wind-magnetopsehre coupling functions. However, it is found that the WINDMI model driven by any of these coupling functions is not fully able to explain the enhancement of SYM-H under northward IMF $B_z$. The SYM-H variations during the entire duration of the storm were only reproduced when the effects of the dense plasma sheet were included in the WINDMI model. The limitations of directly-driven models relying purely on the solar wind parameters and not accounting for the state of the magnetosphere are highlighted by this work.