2.9 Factors Affecting Biogas Production
In order to enhance the performance of the biogas generation process, and to
prevent process failure, certain operating parameters such as
temperature, pH, nutrient addition, mixing ratio, and retention period,
all need to be controlled. Microorganisms are highly sensitive to pH
changes. Buffering is necessary for pH control and therefore an
essential step in the overall operation (Garba and Sambo, 1992).
2.9.1 Temperature
Temperature is an important physicochemical factor in the degradation
of organic wastes and as such the anaerobic process is dependent on
temperature. The temperature has significant effect on biogas production especially when fresh plant material is involved. Two temperature
ranges have been reported to affect tile overall process of biogas
production. These are; tile mesophilic temperatures and thermophilic
temperatures. Tile mesophilic temperature range of 30-40°C has been
reported to effectively aid in degradation of organic wastes that are
not lignified. Increased biogas production was reported in tile
digestion of fresh water weed known as Pistia stratiotes (water lettuce)
at mesophilic temperature of 30 °C.). Tile mesophilic temperature range
is preferred when fresh plant material is involved (Maishanu, 1992) Also
it is easier to maintain the digester at this temperature.
Methane-producing bacteria are, very sensitive to sudden thermal changes
and therefore any drastic change in temperature should be carefully
avoided so that no abrupt decrease in gas production occurs. The
digestion process must thus be designed to operate at constant
temperature conditions. Temperatures above 65°C cause gas production to
stop (Garba and Sambo, 1992).
2.9.2 pH
The anaerobic digestion process can be operated over a pH range of 6.0 —
7.0. As organic acids are produced during the breakdown of cellulose when the pH drops below 7.0, there is a significant inhibition of
rnethanogellic bacteria and tile acid conditions of a pH of 4.0 are
toxic to these bacteria. At a pH of 4.0, tile production of gas will be
very low and later stops (Garba and Sambo, 1992). Several steps such as the introduction of bacteria having cellulolytic capacity, preheating the
media material, milling the media material, chemical treatments with
NaOH, etc, and drying have been shown to improve biogas yield (Itodoet al., 1998). In the absence of water hyacinth, cow manure can
be as an alternative raw material so that the plant will be kept running
even after the water hyacinth has been eradicated.
2.9.3 Carbon to nitrogen (C/N)
Ratio
The relationship between the amount of carbon and nitrogen present in
organic materials is expressed in terms of the Carbon/Nitrogen (C/N) ratio.
A C/N ratio ranging from 20 to 30 is considered optimum for the anaerobic
digestion (FAO, 1996). If the C/N ratio is very high the nitrogen will
be consumed rapidly by methanogens for meeting their protein
requirements and will no longer react on the leftover carbon content of
the material. As a result, gas production will be low. On the other hand,
if the C/N ratio is very low, nitrogen will be liberated and accumulated
in the form of ammonia. Solid concentration in the feed material is also
crucial to ensure sufficient gas production as well as easy mixing and
handling. The concentration of total solids in the input suspension can
be varied within the range of 20 to 100g/liter. In practice, it is
recommended to limit the total solids concentration to the range of 20
to 30 g/liter. In Nepal, 6 kg of cow dung per m³ of digester liquid
volume is used (FAO, 1996). Cow dung has a solid concentration of about
20% and therefore, it is recommended that dung and water are mixed in a
1:1 ratio to attain the desired level of solids. One kilogram of dung
produces about 40 liters of biogas. A family-size biogas plant (two
cubic meters) requires 50 kg of dung and an equal amount of water to
produce 2000 liters of gas per day. This amount of gas suffices the daily
cooking requirement of a family consisting of four to five members.
2.9.4 Consistency and Dilution of Feedstock
All waste materials fed to a biogas plant consist of solid substances
volatile organic matter and non-volatile matter (fixed solids) and
water. During the anaerobic fermentation process, volatile solids undergo
digestion and non-volatile solids remain unaffected. According to a
finding by The Energy and Resources Institute, fresh cattle waste
consists of approximately 20% total solid (TS) and 80% water. TS, in
turn, consists of 70% Volatile solids and 30% fixed solids. For optimum
gas yield through anaerobic fermentation, normally, 8-10% TS in feed is
required. This is achieved by making a slurry of fresh cattle dung in
water in the ratio of 1:1. However, if the dung is in dry form, the
quantity of water has to be increased accordingly to arrive at the
desired consistency of the input (i.e., the ratio could vary from 1:1.25 to
even 1:2). If the dung is too diluted, the solid particles will settle
down into the digester and if it is too thick, the particles impede the
flow of the gas formed at the lower part of the digester. In both cases,
gas production will be less than optimum (Anonymous, 1981). It is also
necessary to remove inert materials such as stones from the inlet before
feeding the slurry into the digester. Otherwise, the effective volume of the digester will decrease.
2.9.5 Water Content
Bacteria take up the available substrates in dissolved form. Therefore,
biogas production and the water content of the initial material are
interdependent. Rilling (2005) reported that when the water content is
below 20% by weight, hardly any biogas is produced. Optimum moisture
content has to be maintained in the digester and the water content
should be kept in the range of 60-95 %. Anaerobic digestion of organics
will proceed best if the input material consists of roughly 8 % solids.
For domestic digesters, TS content should not be too high, otherwise, the substrate would not slide easily through the inlet of the digester and
if toxins are present, such as ammonium in high concentrations, high TS
is likely to affect bacteria more than when the substrate is diluted.
Alternatively, TS content should not be too low, otherwise, the feedstock
is very dilute, and a large digester volume is required. Water content
is one of the very important parameters affecting AD of solid wastes.
There are two main reasons viz.; (a) water makes possible the movement
and growth of bacteria by facilitating the dissolution and transport of
nutrients and (b) water reduces the limitation of mass transfer of
non-homogenous or particulate substrates.
2.9.6 Free Ammonia
A number of studies have cited the inhibitory effects of free ammonia
(NH3) on the metabolism of methanogens. As ammonia is
added to a digester, the pH increases until a chemical equilibrium is
reached. However, as ammonia inhibits methanogen metabolism, VFAs
accumulate, resulting in a lower pH and a lower concentration of free
ammonia. Sterling et al., (2001) concluded that total biogas
production was unaffected by small increases in ammonia nitrogen while
higher increases reduce biogas production to 50% of the original rate.
However, the underlying reason for this effect is still unknown. It was
also found that the free ammonia concentration not only affects the
acetate-utilizing bacteria, but also the hydrolysis and acidification
processes. By controlling the pH value lower it is possible to control the
production of ammonia but it lowers the yield of biogas production.
2.9.7 Seeding
To start up a new anaerobic process, it is critical to use inoculums of
microorganisms to commence the fermentation process. The common seeding
materials include digested sludge from a running biogas plant or
material from sewage. Digested sludge is the best inoculum source for
anaerobic thermophilic digestion of the treatment of an organic fraction of
municipal solid waste at dry conditions (30% TS). Inoculums caused
biogas production rate and efficiency to increase more than two times as
compared to a substrate without inoculums. The addition of fresh cow dung
to the batch reactor as part of the starter improves biogas
production. When poultry litter was used as inoculum for an anaerobic
process methane yield was best on a digester with a content of 75% of
inoculum (Jagadish et al., 2012).
2.9. 8 Particle Size
The production of biogas is also affected by the particle size of the
substrate. Too big a particle size is problematic for microbes to digest
and it can also result in blockage in the digester, whereas small
particle size gives a large surface area for substrate adsorption and
thus allows the increased microbial activity followed by an increase in the
production of gas. A large amount of biogas was obtained from the grounded
water hyacinth than chopped water hyacinth. Degradation of the substrate
and biogas production potential of the water hyacinth could be
significantly increased by pre-treatment such as a reduction of particle
size. These results suggest that the reduction of the particle size of the
substrate in conjunction with the optimized microbial growth could
improve the methane yields in anaerobic digestion processes (Yasini and
Isack, 2016).
2.9.9 Agitation
The close contact between microorganisms and the substrate material is
important for an efficient digestion process. The agitation of the
digester contents has a number of benefits, one of the most obvious
beings that it helps to mix up material, evening out any localized
concentrations, thus also helping to stop the formation of “dead
zones” or scum. In addition, it increases the waste‘s availability to
the bacteria, helps remove and disperse metabolic products, and also acts
to ensure a more uniform temperature within the digester. There have
been some suggestions that efficient mixing enhances methane production,
but the evidence is inconclusive, so it seems likely that this may only
be of noticeable benefit for some systems or operational regimes. Mixing
also promotes heat transfer, particle size reduction as digestion
progresses, and release of produced gas from the digester contents. There
is a significant stirring effect on the anaerobic digestion only when seed
sludge from a biogas plant was used as a starter. In this case, the
experiments without stirring yielded, without starter, only about 50%
of the expected biogas for the investigated substrates.
2.9.10 Total Solids
Total solids mean the number of solid particles in the unit volume of
the slurry and they are usually expressed in the percentage form (FAO/CMS,
(1996). The percentage of total solid should be between 5% and 12%
while other sources reported that the best biogas production occurs when
total solid is ranged from 7% to 10% because of avoiding solids
settling down or impeding the flow of gas formed at the lower part of the digester. Therefore; dilution of organic substrate or wastes with water
to achieve the desirable total solids percentage is required. The total
solid concentration of 99 g TS/l produces the maximum biogas yield as
per the experiment done with different concentrations of total solid in an anaerobic digestion process (Sajeena, 2013).
2.9.11 Effects of Oxygen in
AD
It is quite natural that some amount of oxygen can reach anaerobic
digesters unintentionally as the reactors are operated within an aerobic
open environment, especially through interactions with the surroundings
such as by feeding and mixing. Most anaerobic digesters are therefore
subjected to a minute and varying aerobic loading conditions. The possible
effects of such aeration are neither extensively quantified nor handled
in standard AD models. It is commonly perceived that oxygen acts as an
inhibitory and toxic agent in AD due to the involvement of a strictly
anaerobic microorganism group of acetogens and methanogens (D. Bothejuet al., 2010). Also, the aerobic conversion of soluble organic matter
into CO2 by aerobic respiration is likely. Thus, it was
believed that reactor instabilities, slow start-ups, low methane yields, and even total reactor failures might occur due to oxygen entering
anaerobic digesters. Due to this negative perception, inoculums used in
anaerobic digesters are even de-aerated before commencing reactor
operation; sometimes oxygen scavenging chemicals (e.g. sodium sulfide)
are also added. Conversely, improved hydrolysis of particulate
matter in AD is observed in the presence of oxygen. All non-soluble and
long-chain organic matter should go through this initial hydrolysis
stage before fermentation or methanogenesis, in which the particulate
matter would undergo decomposition and solubilization by the activity of
enzymes (such as protease, amylase, etc.) that are extracellularly
excreted by fermentative (acedogenic) bacteria. Since hydrolysis is
often the rate-limiting reaction stage when the substrate is composed of
particulate organic matter enhanced hydrolysis can greatly benefit the
overall process efficiency. It is commonly known that hydrolysis rates
are significantly higher under aerobic and anoxic conditions compared to
anaerobic conditions. Botheju et al., (2010) demonstrated the
possibility of the existence of an optimum oxygenation level that would
yield a maximum methane generation in AD.
2.9.12 Retention Time
The retention time is the theoretical time that a particle or volume of
liquid added to a digester would remain in the digester. It is
calculated as the volume of the digester divided by the volume added per
day, and it is expressed as days. The solid retention time represents
the average time that the solids remain in the system. The solid
retention time can be determined by dividing the weight of volatile
solids in the system by the weight per unit time of volatile solids
leaving the system. The hydraulic retention time (HRT) is equal to the
solid retention time in completely mixed non-recycled digester systems.
Retention time has an effect on gas production as shown in the results
of (1974). There is a minimum retention time which allows the slowest
growing bacteria to regenerate. Then there is a minimum. Retention time is required to achieve a satisfactory stabilization of the solids, which
Dague shows as 10 days for sewage sludge at 35°C. If the retention time
is cut in half, the gas production rate will drop and the process may
fail due to a condition called wash out where the bacterial cultures
decrease to the point that they are no longer effective. If the
retention time is greater than 10 days at 35°C., the gas production
levels out, and very little additional gas is produced for the additional
time. Therefore, long detention times lead to low efficiency of the
process. There is a tendency to refer to gas production rates in terms
of volumes of gas produced per volume of digester volume. If maximum gas
is desired, the ratio may be four or more volumes/volume per day.
However, if the purpose of the digester is to produce and store a soil
conditioner and to have some gas, as is the case in China, then the
ratio may be very low and has no meaning. Retention time along with the temperature is important from the standpoint of the destruction of
pathogens. If improved health is a consideration, certain minimum values
should be exceeded.
2.9.13 Concentration of the Feed Stocks
Gas production is a function of the solid materials and their
biodegradability in the digester. The more concentrated the solids, the
smaller the digester and the lower the cost of the system. In sewage
treatment plants, efforts are made to concentrate the solids to reduce
the volume and the costs of the digester. The literature about the
Indian digesters as reported by ESCAP (1980) implies that an optimal
solids concentration of 7 to 9% of the feed should be used. However,
systems have been designed to use as little water as possible. For
example, Amon (2007) points out the advantage of dairy manure (10 to
13% solids) are that it can be added to the digester directly without
dilution. If the manure has stood for a few days some water may have to
be added to slurry the material for introduction into the digester. In
Israel the manure is scrapped from the cattle pens with bedding which is
either asphalt or concrete. Sterling (2001) reports that he has fed this
manure with only small quantities of water at 16 to 18% solids content
without difficulty. Batch dry digesters have operated with solids
concentrations at 60%. The batch dry digesters with high solids
concentrations appear to be an effective means of producing gas cheaply.
Currently efforts are underway to manage and optimize the gas production
for crop residues and urban solid wastes in landfills having very high
solids.
2.9.14 Organic Loading Rate
The rate at which biomass is supplied to the digester is referred to as
the volumetric organic loading rate and is commonly expressed in terms
of grams of volatile solids per liter of digester capacity per day (gm
VS/l-day). Different loading rates can be obtained by either changing
the concentration of the solids in the influent or varying the flow
through the digester. In practice the solids concentrations tend to be
kept constant, and thus the flow rate is changed.