Prenatal cases with rare RIT1 variants causing severe fetal
hydrops and death
Ieva Miceikaite1, 2, Geske Sidsel Bak3, Martin J. Larsen1, 2, Britta
Schlott Kristiansen1,
Pernille Mathiesen Torring1
1 Department of Clinical Genetics, Odense University
Hospital, Odense, Denmark
2 Human Genetics Unit, Department of Clinical
Research, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southern Denmark,
Odense, Denmark
3 Fetal Medicine Unit, Department of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Odense University Hospital, Odense, Denmark
*Correspondence: Geske Sidsel Bak geske.bak@rsyd.dk
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Author Contributions :
Ieva Miceikaite: Contributed to conception and design for this
manuscript, collection of the data; wrote and edited the paper, prepared
the table and the figure, and approved the final version to be
published.
Geske Sidsel Bak: Contributed to conception and design; acquisition of
data, including ultrasound pictures; and drafting the case descriptions.
Revised the paper and approved the final version to be published.
Martin Jakob Larsen: Contributed to conception and design, performed the
analysis and interpretation of the data, critically revised the draft,
and approved the final version to be published.
Britta Schlott Kristiansen: Contributed to acquisition of the data,
critically revised the draft, and approved the final version to be
published.
Pernille Mathiesen Torring: Contributed to conception and design, and
acquisition of data. Revised the paper and approved the final version to
be published.
Abstract/ Key clinical message :
Here we describe two clinical prenatal cases with rare de novoRIT1 variants which showed more severe clinical manifestations than
other Noonan Syndrome genotypes, resulting in fetal death. It is
recommended that extra attention would be exercised when these variants
are detected, and an appropriate patient counselling would be provided.
Keywords : prenatal screening, Noonan syndrome, RIT1, cystic
hygroma, hydrops fetalis
INTRODUCTION
Noonan Syndrome (NS) is a multisystemic developmental disorder with an
incidence of 1:1000-2500 in the general population [1]. It follows
an autosomal dominant inheritance. 30-75% of patients with NS have an
affected parent; nonetheless, NS can also be caused by a de novovariant. The disease has a wide spectrum of phenotypical features, which
are associated with different genotypes. At present, 11 genes have been
reported to cause NS when carrying a pathogenic variant [2]. Based
on the chromosomal locations and genes involved, NS is divided into 12
types.
The RIT1 (Ras-Like Without CAAX 1) gene is associated with Noonan
Syndrome type 8 (NS8, OMIM #615355). The RIT1 gene is located on
chromosome 1q22. The protein coded by RIT1 is involved in MAPK-dependent
signaling pathways (involved in stress-mediated activation of
p38-MK2-HSP27-AKT complex in cell-survival mechanism) and NGF (Nerve
Growth Factor) dependent nerve growth and differentiation [3].
Proteins coded by a mutated RIT1 gene cause hyperactivation of MAPK-ERK
or transactivation of ELK pathways, participating in NS pathogenesis
[3]. The gain-of-function mutations of RIT1 are responsible for
around 5% of all NS cases, making RIT1 one of the most common genetic
causes of NS [4].
The common distinctive characteristic in individuals with NS8 is
hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, which is seen in at least 50% of the cases
with a mutated RIT1 gene [4-6]. Congenital heart disease in NS gives
one of the worst prognoses, as almost 25% of all NS patients die within
a year due to heart failure [1]. Other more frequently observed
characteristics among these patients are pulmonary stenosis and atrial
or ventricular septal defects [5, 6].
Webbed and short neck is more common in RIT1 patients; however, short
stature, pectus deformity, and intellectual disability are less common,
compared to patients carrying mutations in other NS-associated genes
[3, 7, 8].
Prenatally, NS is suspected in cases with high nuchal translucency (NT),
a cystic hygroma, or hydrops fetalis [9]. Prenatal lymphatic
malfunctions are more often observed in RIT1 NS cases [5], which
result in high birth weight and possible complications.
Here we describe two prenatally detected NS cases with pathogenic RIT1
variants, which resulted in severe fetal hydrops and death.
PRESENTATION OF CASE 1
A healthy nulliparous woman was referred to our tertiary fetal medicine
clinic at the gestational age of (GA) 15+3 weeks. The
family history revealed no congenital abnormalities and no
consanguinity. The combined first trimester screening (cFTR) was done in
the primary care center at GA 12+5. An ultrasound scan
showed a cystic hygroma with NT of 14.2 mm. The risk of Trisomy 21 was
1:8. Chorionic villus sampling (CVS) was done the following day. A
normal male karyotype was reported in the chromosomal microarray. An
early ultrasound of the fetal anatomy was performed at
15+3 that showed a persistent cystic hygroma with NT
of 14 mm and large jugular lymphatic sacs at each side of the neck
measuring 24 x 16 mm for the left side and 20 x 10 mm for the right
side. The fetus was not hydropic.
The patient was offered a trio exome analysis and screened for variants
in known Noonan-associated genes. At GA 19+5, another
ultrasound of fetal anatomy was performed that showed smaller NT (12.4
mm) and jugular lymphatic sacs at both sides of neck, in the axial view
of 7 x 10 mm on the left side and 5 x 8 mm on the right side. No other
malformations were observed. At GA 20+4, the
sequencing result showed a de novo heterozygous pathogenic RIT1
variant (c.268A>G (p.Met90Val), NM_006912.6). The couple
was counseled about NS and their options. They decided to continue the
pregnancy. At GA 28+6, an ultrasound showed normal
growth with an estimated fetal weight of 1265 g. The enlarged NT and
jugular lymphatic sacs had disappeared. A new ultrasound was planned for
GA 34, but the patient came in at GA 31+2 due to
reduced fetal movements. Bilateral severe hydrothorax (chylothorax) was
revealed by the ultrasound. The fetal echocardiography was normal.
Betamethasone was given for lung maturation. The intrauterine drainage
of the hydrothorax was only possible to insert at one side. It confirmed
chylothorax. However, the fetus died in utero the day after the
drainage was performed. It had hypertelorism and a broad webbed neck,
but otherwise no characteristic Noonan features. The couple did not opt
for autopsy. A postnatal picture and ultrasound scan findings can be
seen in Figure 1 as Case 1.
PRESENTATION OF CASE 2
The patient was a nulliparous woman with a history of 2 years of
infertility, but otherwise healthy, who became spontaneously pregnant.
The family history contained no congenital abnormalities and no
consanguinity. The combined first trimester screening was performed at
GA 12+3, which showed a cystic hygroma with a large NT
of 10.2 mm and mild cutaneous edema at the thorax and abdomen. The risk
of Trisomy 21 was 1:3. She was informed about the risks of genetic
diseases, fetal malformations, and intrauterine fetal demise. She was
offered CVS and was informed about the option to apply for termination
of the pregnancy. She chose CVS, and a normal chromosomal microarray
result was received. Due to the residual risk of genetic disease, she
was offered trio whole exome sequencing. An ultrasound of the fetal
anatomy at GA 15+6 still showed a cystic hygroma with
NT of 15 mm. Furthermore, the fetus had pyelectasis of a slightly
hyperechogenic left kidney.
At GA 18+2, a likely pathogenic, heterozygous de
novo variant in the RIT1 gene (c.245T>G (p.Phe82Cys),
NM_006912.6) was detected by trio whole exome sequencing. The couple
was counseled about NS. Ultrasound showed an NT of 18 mm, bilateral
pyelectasis, and mild ascites. The patient decided to continue the
pregnancy and was evaluated with ultrasound every 1-2 weeks due to
increasing fetal hydrops. At GA 19+6, there was
bilateral pyelectasis (hydronephrosis). Fetal echocardiography was
normal.
At GA 23+6, she developed mild polyhydramnios with an
amnion fluid index (AFI) of 25 cm. At GA 26+6, she
still had mild polyhydramnios, but at GA 28+2, the
polyhydramnios became severe, AFI 48 cm, and it started to bother the
patient. At the same time, fetal hydrops kept increasing with moderate
to severe hydrothorax, and ascites that enlarged the abdominal
circumference to +12 in Z-score, giving an estimated fetal weight of
3000 g (equivalent to +130% of normal for the GA). The NT was 23 mm and
the fetus had large jugular lymphatic sacs on each side of the neck. The
flow in the umbilical cord had an absent-end diastolic flow. The patient
was offered therapeutic amniocentesis after 48 hours of fetal lung
maturation with betamethasone.
The patient came back at GA 28+6 for the amniocentesis
and pediatric counseling. Her condition had worsened during the previous
24 hours; sleep problems and dyspnea had appeared due to the large
uterus. Further testing showed Mirror syndrome resembling HELLP
syndrome/preeclampsia. The amniocentesis was cancelled, and she had a
subacute cesarean section. She was offered ex utero intrapartumtreatment (EXIT) with intubation of the baby during cesarean before
clamping of the umbilical cord. She declined that option, but otherwise
full treatment was planned. The newborn was severely hydropic at birth.
It was intubated, ventilated, and given
Curosurf® (poractant alfa). Bilateral pleural drainage
was inserted. The treatment had no effect and resuscitation was
terminated after 27 minutes; the newborn died shortly after. It was
severely hydropic with flattened facies. The birth weight of 2935 g was
equivalent to +109% of normal for the GA and calculated to be
>10 SD, based on Hadlock [10]. The couple did not opt
for autopsy of the newborn. A postnatal picture and ultrasound scan
findings can be seen in Figure 1 as Case 2.
DISCUSSION
The two clinical prenatal cases described in this paper present rare
RIT1 variants with similar, and different-than-usual NS manifestations.
Both variants are situated in the beginning of exon 5 of the RIT1 gene.
The majority of known NS-associated pathogenic variants cluster in exons
4 and 5 (ClinVar)[5]. These variants (in switch II region of RIT1),
described by Milosavljevic et al. [5], lead to a change of amino
acid which is in a conserved sequence of the gene.
The RIT1 variant c.268A>G (p.Met90Val) identified in Case
1, was previously detected in 4 prenatal cases, which all presented with
hydrops fetalis (Table 1). In Case 2, a RIT1 variant
c.245T>G (p.Phe82Cys) was detected that was previously
described once in a fetus with hydrops fetalis, CNS malformations, and
congenital heart defect associated with NS [9].
A number of publications describe postnatally identified variants in the
same codons as the two RIT1 variants in Cases 1 and 2; however, these
involved different nucleotides and resulted in a different amino acid
after substitution, which presented milder Noonan characteristic
symptoms [7, 8, 11-13]. To the best of our knowledge, there are no
exact postnatally identified variants described in the literature
matching the two cases we present. For all the cases with prenatally
identified variants in RIT1, matching the variants described in Cases 1
and 2, intrauterine fetal demise or death during labor was reported at
GA 18-32 (Table 1). This suggests more severe clinical manifestations
than other Noonan genotypes and a worse prognosis in cases with the RIT1
variants we have described in this case report.
A very recently published study, learning the genetic causes of
non-immune hydrops fetalis, showed that 29% of the cases were solely
due to gene variants in MAPK-dependent signaling pathways [14]. All
of them were de novo variants, including a RIT1 variant. It
indicates that Noonan-associated gene variants are a rather frequent
finding in cases with hydrops fetalis. Furthermore, that study supports
the use of exome sequencing for prenatal diagnosis in cases with hydrops
fetalis as the ones described here.
Based on our described clinical cases and the outcomes of other recent
studies, it is advised to remain attentive about the prognosis in cases
where a cystic hygroma or hydrops fetalis and a rare de novo RIT1
variant are identified prenatally, as it might result in a
more-severe-than-usual Noonan outcome resulting in fetal death. Thus, it
is recommended that the patients be counselled about these potential
risks.