loading page

The impact that intense ‘fetal-physiology’ training has on inter-observer agreement in interpreting intrapartum cardiotocograph traces in comparison to the classical ‘pattern-recognition’ approach: a prospective observational study
  • Juan de Dios Gutierrez HenaresOrcid,
  • David Diaz Gomez,
  • Edwin Chandraharan
Juan de Dios Gutierrez Henares
St George's University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
Author Profile
David Diaz Gomez
St George's University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
Author Profile
Edwin Chandraharan
Tianjin Central Hospital of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Author Profile


Abstract Objective: To explore the level of agreement as well as the contribution of human-factors on CTG interpretation in a hospital where a high intense, ‘fetal physiology-based’ training on CTG-interpretation was implemented by a dedicated CTG-Team. Design: Prospective observational study Setting: Tertiary Hospital, UK Population: A total of 25 midwives and 7 doctors (≈10% of staff) Method: interpretation of 5 anonymised colour-printed copies of 5 different CTGs using a questionnaire (160 CTG interpretations) using local CTG-guidelines (pattern-recognition approach) and Types of hypoxia (fetal-physiology). Results: Interpretation of CTG by type of hypoxia compared against CTG-guidelines presented better Proportion of concordance (PC=76.1% vs 61.2%, P=0.006) and slightly better reliability (K= 0.37 (0.35–0.39) vs 0.33 (0.32–0.36)). Doctors rely most in fetal-physiology than midwives who rely most in guidelines. Overall, 68% of the staff felt confident or very confident in CTG interpretation. In general, Self-reported confidence on CTG interpretation and fetal-physiology knowledge increased with the level of seniority. Conclusions: ‘Fetal-physiology-based’ training increases level of self-reported confidence and level of fetal-physiology knowledge leading to better inter-observer agreement and reliability in CTG interpretation especially when considering type of hypoxia in CTG-classification. Funding: JG collected the data as part of a Self-funded university MSc program. A secondary analysis of the data was performed to elaborate this manuscript. There is no source of funding to declare by the rest of co-authors in this paper. Keywords: Fetal-physiology, Cardiotocography Interpretation, Intrapartum fetal monitoring, Inter-observer agreement,