As clinicians, we are familiar with the Hippocratic albatross ‘Primum
non nocere’, ‘first, do not harm’. We understand that every weapon in
our clinical armour chest is double-edged, and every cure has a
potential harm, this has never more true than during the global pandemic
of SARS-CoV-2.
In these unprecedented times, the UK government acted swiftly to try to
first contain the virus and then flatten the peak of admissions to
hospital. On 16th March, pregnant women were placed in
the most vulnerable, ‘at risk’, category advising them to self-isolate.
This message has been carefully observed by women. Whilst the press
‘floods’ us with images of overwhelmed hospitals, the normal patient
throughput in obstetrics and gynaecology to semi-urgent care is
anecdotally at an all-time low. Women with pain and bleeding, in early
pregnancy, are staying away from hospital. Antenatal women are not
presenting with, ‘threatened’, labour nor reduced fetal movements. The
true incidence of these conditions has not simply declined. Certainly,
some of these women are not presenting and are suffering at home.
According to NHS England figures, there was a 29% drop in numbers of
people attending Accident and Emergency departments in March 2020 –1.5
million compared with 2.2 million in March 2019
(NHS
England figures). The Royal College of Midwives became concerned
patients were not attending scheduled appointments for pregnancy care,
this led to a joint statement with the Royal College of Obstetricians
and Gynaecologists (RCOG) emphasising the importance of antenatal care.
There is concern that women may be self-isolating at home to their
detriment. If they do develop medical problems, they may defer
contacting medical professionals until symptoms are severe, and in some
cases life-threatening, for example in ectopic pregnancies.
In order to limit hospital-footfall, women are being asked to attend
alone. In normal circumstances, partners provide-support during
antenatal ultrasounds or consultations, a time which some may receive
upsetting news. Additionally, with centralisation of services to
depleted staff numbers, there is less choice in the location of
pregnancy-related care and birthplace. Important appointments are being
missed, and in obstetrics, ‘the clock’ does not stop because of
Covid-19.
A wider part of the role of the obstetrician is safeguarding. Children
are out of school and domestic violence prevalent 1.
We are missing opportunities to identify vulnerable women, and to
intervene for the safety and wellbeing of her and her children. Much
emotional and practical support is now also lacking. Isolation to
prevent coronavirus spread means grandparents cannot visit new babies,
families struggle with the provision of childcare for existing children.
The networking women partake in at antenatal classes, nor the support
from visiting postnatal midwives nor breastfeeding support is happening.
This, combined with the anxiety and fear felt during a global pandemic2, may be associated with a resurgence in postnatal
mental health disorders.
Despite this difficult time, there are positives. Patient care has been
rapidly remodelled across the country with services streamlined in
record time. For example, ‘one stop’, antenatal booking clinics
encompass ultrasound, venepuncture and a face-to-face midwife consult.
Previously this necessitated multiple appointments, with impacts on work
and family life. Like most areas of medicine, clinics are being
performed via telephone or online conference calls. This is time and
cost-saving for both parties. The necessity or validity of
investigations is being questioned more ruthlessly, perhaps as we should
be doing routinely.
With reduced patient numbers, women in early pregnancy are being triaged
and seen faster. The number of invasive surgical procedures performed
for miscarriage and ectopic pregnancies has plummeted (University
Hospital Southampton data 2020). Partly because women are encouraged to
have less invasive management, thereby circumventing surgical risk.
However, fewer ultrasounds are being performed for vague symptoms.
Resulting in fewer women having, ‘pregnancies of unknown location’, a
diagnosis fraught with iatrogenic anxiety and distress. Women are
feeling more empowered to self-manage conditions that we have always
advocated self-care for in the first instance. Fewer women are
requesting induction of labour, usually a huge burden of work on
innundated labour wards.
By responding to the global pandemic, we are likely causing harm to some
of the women we have a duty of care for, we plan to look at national
data to assess the level of secondary harm caused. The ameliorating
benefits are that the NHS is being treated as a precious commodity, it
is imperative that innovative changes and optimal uses of services bring
about long term benefit. The UK healthcare system will change forever as
a result of Covid-19; it is the responsibility of doctors and patients
to ensure that this is for the better and to minimise harm to women and
their families in the meantime.