Citation Standards
- All data sets and code are cited in the text as References
- Persistent URI or DOI for data sets and code
- Citation in Reference section contains author/title/year/URI
Data, Code, and Materials Transparency
Are the following present and sufficient to independently reproduce all
claimed results?
For reused public datasets:
- data URIs, program code, statistics
scripts
For new data and resources
- New data available at a trusted digital repository OR all available
in paper
- Variables, parameters, treatment conditions, and observation
(number)
- Full procedures for collection, preprocessing, cleaning, or
generating the data
- Code, scripts, codebooks, algorithms (URI or all in paper)
- Research materials (description and source) and procedures necessary
to conduct an independent replication of the research.
Exceptions for ethical or legal restrictions to reproducible research
- Conditions on the dataset or materials that restrict researcher
access and use
- Access protocol for data or materials
- Access to software and other documentation
- Indicate all data and materials without the above constraints
Resources available at a community-endorsed public repository
- Authors request delay of access until publication
- Do the editors identify any factors that might delay peer review/
delay acceptance for publication/ require editorial explanation upon
publication /need expression of editorial concern / risk author
might need to retract because of reproducibility concerns?