Evaluating HYDRUS-1D for Inverse Estimating Parameters of the van
Genuchten-Mualem model from Daily Soil Moisture and Weather data
Abstract
Knowledge of the Soil Water Retention Function (SWRF) is important for
irrigation management, soil water modelling and quantification of soil
phys- ical health. However, determining the SWRF is laborious, requiring
spe- cialized skills and equipment. Multi-depth soil moisture data is
routinely measured and collected by Australian farmers to guide
irrigation man- agement. This data provides an extraordinary opportunity
to better un- derstand and characterize the hydraulic properties of
agricultural soils if a means of inversely determining the SWRF from
daily multi-depth soil moisture data existed. While the SWRF has been
solved using the soil water program HYDRUS-1D to inversely determine the
van Genuchten- Mualem (VGM) parameters from inflow/outflow type
experiments, its im- plementation in real-world, multi-layer soils is
rare. This study evaluated the ability of the HYDRUS-1D model to
determine the VGM parameters from daily soil moisture and weather data
obtained at two Tasmanian field sites. The experiments were conducted as
four separate 100-day periods from two sites for three soil depths,
including five different optimized pa- rameter sets, and three different
initial parameter value sources with each of six variants, producing 420
inverse modelling tests. The quality of these tests was assessed
according to five criteria: (i) modelling robustness, (ii) simulation
accuracy, (iii) prediction accuracy, (iv) parameter uniqueness, and (v)
estimation stability. Overall, 322 of 420 simulations failed due to
non-convergence. The accuracy of the successfully completed simulations
was poor, with an average R 2 value of 0.460
and an average RMSE value of 0.066 between the simulated and measured
soil moisture. The prediction accuracy of the completed predictions of
VGM parameters was less than 30%. Furthermore, predicted VGM parameters
showed nonuniqueness and stability below 50%.